不准作台灣人 Not allowed to be Taiwanese


廢除國籍法第九條 Repeal Article 9 of the Nationality Law

第九條
外國人… 申請歸化者, 應提出喪失其原有國籍之證明…
Article 9
An alien who is naturalized ... shall submit a certificate to prove the loss of his (her) original nationality...

再也看不到父母 Never see your parents again

放棄原國籍一日欲見父母需簽證, 萬一資格不符?

After giving up original citizenship one day you wish to visit your parents. What if you don't meet visa requirements?

家也沒 Lose your home

但若不放棄原國籍, 如國有地, 離婚、 繼承, 無承租權。 But if one does not give up original citizenship, e.g., land rented from the government, at divorce or inheritance, one has no right to rent.

故今非「凝聚愛國情操」, 「驗證忠誠度」而放棄原國籍, 卻多如因辦理房地、貸款、手機門號等。 So we see it is not for some patriotic issue for which one gives up original citizenship these days, but instead usually to apply for land, loans, cell phones, etc.

淪為無國籍人 End up stateless

聯合國刊物「難民」報導, 許多越南女子嫁給台灣人後淪為「無國籍」的悲慘情況: UN Refugees Magazine 2007/9

一邊推動「難民法」,一邊遭成難民。 One one hand pushing for a refugee asylum law, on the other creating more refugees.

偏頗統計 Lopsided statistics

統計中哪些族群敢「歸化」, 再比較美國的。 Check the statistics of what groups dare to naturalize. Compare the US.

我就是不懂您們台灣人拿美國雙重國籍是最平常不過的事, 而人家要您們的卻叫人家先放棄自己的。 I don't understand how you Taiwanese think it's only natural to have so many US dual citizenships, but when we want one of yours, you tell us to give up our original citizenship first.

總結 Conclusion

勞民傷財, 人民與政府的, 只製造很多手續, 本國人國籍數卻未限, 諷刺「反歧視條款」。 What a waste for both people and government. Just makes lots of red tape. The number of citizenships Taiwanese can have is however not limited. 大國早不再浪費時間查這些

張忠謀、殷琪可以有雙重國籍, 但外籍新娘不行。 好好扮演妳的台灣之子的媽角色。 毀掉妳過去,就不敢落跑。

引述 Quotes

Taipei Times 2007/09/10

Dozens of organizations argue that unless it ends the discriminatory process by which foreign spouses can obtain citizenship, Taiwan will be undeserving of the UN.

我國國籍法制與實施現況之研究

325頁 「我們默許國人可以有雙重國籍, 外國人則需放棄外國籍始能歸化我國籍所衍生之不合理情況, 這在立法理由中未說清楚。 這當初是基於大中國的觀念… 原屬國籍幾乎全部來自東南亞」

336頁 「國際化全球化後有外籍人士對於歸化我國時是否可以因平等互惠而仍有雙重國籍…」, 至少不要「互惠之相反」

344頁 「…構想成為一九二九年國籍法的原動力, 惟時代潮流不斷改變…修正方向與時俱進。」

Immigration proposals are worth supporting; 移民法將增列反歧視條款

These rules make a mockery of the fact that many Taiwanese possess citizenship of other countries

立法院 Legislative Yuan

意見可給徐中雄委員辦公室。 Ideas can be forwarded to Legislator Xu Zhongxiong's office.

連結 Links

「沒錢沒身份」行動聯盟
南洋台灣姊妹會
Forumosa: dual citizenship
台灣人權促進會 Taiwan Association for Human Rights
台灣移民署 Taiwan Immigration Bureau, 外籍配偶保護諮詢專線 Foreign Spouse Hotline: 0800-088885

其他 Etc.

本文之較早、大版 Older more verbose version of this article.)


積丹尼Dan Jacobson

Last modified: 2008-04-25 14:53:42 +0800